Leslie Feldt, Contributing Writer EDITORIAL
Finance & Accounting

Zero-Based Budgeting Revisited: When It Works and When It Doesn’t

Zero-Based Budgeting Revisited: When It Works and When It Doesn't

Last January, I did something I’d never done before: I went through every recurring charge on our credit card statement and asked a simple question about each one. Would I sign up for this again today? Three streaming services, a meal kit we’d stopped using and a premium app subscription didn’t make the cut. We saved a surprising amount just by questioning what had become automatic.

That’s the core idea behind zero-based budgeting. Instead of starting with last year’s numbers and adjusting, every expense has to be justified from scratch. It’s an approach that’s come in and out of fashion over the years, and it’s worth a fresh look.

How Zero-Based Budgeting Works

In traditional incremental budgeting, departments start from last year’s spending and propose increases or decreases. In zero-based budgeting, every line starts at zero. Managers must explain what each activity costs, why it’s needed and what value it delivers. Spending is then approved based on priorities rather than history.

When It Works Well

Zero-based budgeting can be very effective in the right circumstances:

  • Cost transformation programs. When a company needs to reset its cost base significantly.
  • Discretionary spending. Areas like travel, marketing, consulting and software where costs tend to creep.
  • After major changes. Mergers, restructurings or strategy shifts where history no longer reflects needs.
  • Building cost awareness. Encouraging managers to think like owners about every dollar.

When It Doesn’t

The approach has real drawbacks. It’s time-consuming, and applying it to every line every year can exhaust teams. It can also discourage long-term investments whose payoff isn’t immediately visible. And for fixed or contractual costs, starting from zero adds effort without much insight.

A Smarter Middle Ground

Many organizations now use zero-based thinking selectively. They apply it to specific cost categories on a rotating basis, pair it with clear strategic priorities and use spending analytics to target areas where costs have drifted. Technology makes it easier to analyze spend by category and benchmark against peers.

The Bottom Line

Zero-based budgeting isn’t a cure-all, but it’s a powerful tool when used deliberately. Questioning every expense can uncover significant savings and build a culture where managers think carefully about value, not just last year’s baseline. The key is knowing where to apply it and where traditional budgeting works just fine.

Target the categories where costs tend to creep, rotate your focus over time and tie decisions to strategic priorities so investment in growth isn’t sacrificed for short-term savings. Done well, zero-based thinking keeps spending lean without burning out your teams. Sometimes the simplest question, “Would we sign up for this again today?”, turns out to be the most valuable one.